Some thoughts on reading "The Criticism of Jin Shengtan of the Water Margin"

1. Lu Zhishen is really cute. Among the one hundred and eight people, I am afraid that only he can truly be regarded as a chivalrous person. For my friend Lin Chong, I can escort them all the way to Cangzhou. She is willing to take legal action for a few weak women she doesn't know. But he was too grumpy, too rude, and not that cute.

2. Wu Song has no moral concept at all. To fight Jiang's god for Shi En is black and black. Calling Pan Jinlian has no shame, mainly because of human relations. In front of a group of neighbors, ripping Pan's clothes and digging out his liver is similar to Nagisa Oshima's movies - there is a sexual foundation in violence. Of course, Wu Song is not unfamiliar with women. Talking to and fighting with Sun Erniang is completely obscene. Killing the real "sister-in-law", but gossip with other "sister-in-law", can be worthy of a smile.

3. Hua Rong is fake and elegant. The appearance is splendid and brilliant, worse than many rough men. Song Jiang rescued the wife of Hua Rong's colleague Liu Zhizhai. Hua Rong was unhappy and said that she should not be rescued, she deserved to be raped. To earn Qin Ming, Hua Rong killed his family.

4. Yan Po persuaded Song Jiang to stay overnight, and at the same time pulled Song Jiang and Yan Po Xi, both praised and attracted the former, and scolded and cherished the latter, a good article. The pampered parents and daughters are slender. Song Jiang asked for a letter bag, but Yan Poxi said, "If you don't pay it back, you won't pay it back," in a very cute tone. The author suddenly described Yan Poxi as a "juvenile", maybe she was really boyish. It can also be regarded as a foreshadowing of Song Jiang's sexual orientation.

5. Lin Chong burst into tears when he heard that his wife had committed suicide by hanging. Jin Shengtan said, "Cry really hard, let it go fast, really hero, really Lin Chong." But he said before: "Lin Chong is naturally a high-ranking person, but his writing is just too cruel. See what he can count, he can endure it, and he can handle it. Being in prison and doing thorough work are all scary. In this world, people like this are sure to do a career, but they also have a lot of vitality." Those who have relatives and friends may wish to replace them, and they will know how ruthless Lin Chongxin is. I liked it very much when I was a child. He, Zhou Yemang's role adds a sense of Hamlet, and now I can't like it anymore.

6. Pan Jinlian and Pan Qiaoyun only have names when they appear on the stage, and the words "that woman" are all behind them. They don't deserve names. The two women were all torn to pieces, and the author hated them to the core.

7. When Shi Naian wrote the story of "The Prostitute", there was a comment. The general idea is that no matter who the woman is, as long as she is flattering and paying her money, she will usually cheat. Man, this isn't Madame Bovary.

8. Hu Sanniang's whole family was killed, and she was betrothed to Wang Aihu, the defeated general. At the end, she wrote "I have to thank you". Is this a human word?

9. Jin Shengtan has a very touching passage: "The feeling of the world is not deeper than suffering together, and the love in life is not more important than dealing with a long time. If you are in trouble, you have the promise of life and death, but if you deal with it for a long time, then There is a real friendship.”

10. Song Jiang was "in Yuncheng", but "famous all over the world". At that time, there was no media and a small local person, how could reputation management be so successful? There is a detail that Zhu Di went to Song Taigongzhuang to find him, and went straight into the house to open the cellar, saying that Song Jiang had said that he could come here to hide when he had something to do. Its heart-to-heart is evident.

11. After Qin Ming joined Qingzhou, he scolded the prefect of Murong for "killing my whole family". Wasn't the scolding wrong? Wasn't this what Song Jiang, Huarong and others did? In addition, other court officials, such as Hu Yanzhuo and Zhang Qing, were originally people in the system, why did they prefer to fall into trouble when they heard Song Jiang say, "We will recruit An Feng's wife and Yinzi together in the future"? These people in the system whose families were wiped out and their jobs were cut off, eat and live with their enemies every day, how do they do psychological construction?

12. Lu Zhishen saw Lin Chong again after a few years, and suddenly asked, "Has there been any news from Sister-in-law recently?" This sentence is so heartwarming and touching.

13. Wu Yong was going to the Daming Mansion to invite Lu Junyi to go up the mountain. "It's just that there is one less strange-looking companion to go with me." Li Kui immediately said, "I'll go, I'll go." He also knew that he was "weird." Li Kui is definitely the number one mental patient in Liangshan Boli. In order to earn Zhu Di's entry, he hacked a 4-year-old child with an axe. Crazy and unreasonable.

14. When Lu Junyi listened to Wu Yong's fortune-telling, "there is something to do in the southeast", he actually thought that it was his own merits and careers to wipe out Liangshanbo. Outside the members of Beijing, watching the sky, a landlord actually planned to confront an armed terrorist group. It's not called a "hero".

15. When Lu Junyi and Shi Xiu were imprisoned, Liang Shan wrote a "headless post" to the Daming House, and you can look at the words of Chen Lin scolding Cao Cao. Among them, the two sentences of "talking and laughing, encouraging them to leave" are quite interesting. "The righteous husband and wife, the filial son and the grandson, the good people, the prudent officials, don't panic, and each has a safe career", which can be seen as irony.

16. Qin Ming, Hu Yanzhuo and the like, it is true that there is no way for them to fall into the grass. But Guan Sheng is not. It is strange that he is said to be like Guan Yu everywhere, but it is written that he voluntarily stayed in Liangshanbo. There is a foreshadowing in the previous article. After Ruan Xiaoqi told Guan Sheng how life in Liangshan was, Guan Sheng "was restless that night, walked out of the Central Army to see the moon, the sky was full of cold, frost and flowers were everywhere, and he sighed endlessly."

17. Wu Yong attacked Zengtoushi again, and instead of taking revenge with Chao Gai, he said, "There is nothing to do in the warm spring, just to fight for fun", which is terrible.

18. Lu Junyi took Shi Wengong, and according to Chao Gai's will, "The Avenger is the master of the cottage", Song Jiang pretended to push him as the leader, Wu Yong showed everyone, Wu Song, Liu Tang, and Lu Zhishen immediately came to persuade Song Jiang to be the boss, and others to do them. Dissatisfied, what a vivid "office politics" scene.

19. Liangshan people all follow the same routine. Dong Ping wanted to marry Cheng Taishou's daughter, so he killed Cheng Taishou's family and took the daughter. From now on, these tragic women will live with their annihilation enemies without complaint.

20. In the whole "Water Margin", there is no justice and no loyalty. When they kill people, they talk about "morality" because they can't find any other better "reason". Not everyone deserves to be liked. Let others join in, there is no "right way", the only means is to "cut people's backs", destroy the most precious things in other people's life, and then promise a poor "replacement", and these people are often "overjoyed".

21. "Water Margin" is a story belonging to the bottom people, and it is a cool article by Sanhe Great God. The resentment and envy of the intellectual class, the disgust and desire for women, the obsession and greed for promotion, wealth, and violence cannot be concealed. I remember that around 2016, when I opened Kuaishou and clicked into a video from the Northeast, the same path: "Is the Golden Scale a Thing in the Pool" + "I'm Drinking and Drunk", behind which are the shadows of "Water Margin".

22. Song Jiang is the master of thick black studies. Throughout the book, he has low self-esteem, does not trust people, and takes advantage of people's faces. Only such a person has become the leader of Liang Shanbo. But in reality, how can such a person be in "Liangshan Park"?