Black Mouth - Unconditional Basic Income

I feel that many netizens have misunderstood, so Xiuwen will first come to the conclusion. The editor does not oppose the "basic income" (UBI) policy, but opposes the #UBI policy without good financial planning . Netizens who have doubts, please read the full text. And please think about it together, whether to do UBI directly, or to make up the financial gap first, or maybe, is there any magic way to fill the gap and implement UBI without being strongly rebounded by the people?

The following report is completely utopian, which is not the same as the pragmatic tone of its party core "national governance". The policy is not to be shouted. If you really want to implement this bill, please come up with a white paper and use it to shout about the people. what advocacy groups do

#Please help Cai Legislator to hire a math tutor

Exclusive" In response to the unknown impact of the epidemic and the bailout chaos, the People's Party studies the feasibility of "basic income"

Letter Media] https://reurl.cc/Kk9plg

What is Unconditional Basic Income (UBI)? Simply put, it means that the government gives you #basic expenses and funds that can "live". As for the extent to which this "survival" has to live, it depends on what goals the policy aims to achieve and whether the government can afford this cash flow. Faucet

Let's first estimate how much money will be spent on this policy, and separate some "alive" conditions

#Food

If you look at the cost of meals at 100/day (of course, it is an underestimate), it will cost about 3000/month, and if the whole Taiwanese are 23 million, it will cost 0.828 trillion a year.

#live

It is about 4000/month in the distant place, and the whole Taiwan needs 1.104 trillion a year.

#yiyule

neglect

This figure must be compared with something to see that this policy is very absurd in the current Taiwan

Forward-looking plan: 0.8824 trillion in 8 years

Taiwan 2019 tax: 2.4 trillion

And the answer of the financial resources in the text of the report turned out to be

"As for the source of funds for the 'basic income', some non-governmental organizations advocate the allocation of energy tax and carbon tax. Without changing the existing large tax structure, an additional asset gain or holding tax will be levied, and then the basic income will be distributed equally. Income is equal to paying everyone's cost of having a basic living area, and it is also a way to practice housing justice."

You talk about how to get the money for a forward-looking plan without changing the existing big tax structure , or suddenly increase the tax by 3/4 a year, #do the math and then speak hard ?

First think about how to solve the bankruptcy problem of several major funds? Saying you're in the #financecommittee makes me want to cry

-------------------------------------------------------

Finally, let's talk about the concept of UBI. In fact, the concept is good, just like environmental protection, abolition, and human rights. # The starting point is all good and ideal, but these ideals must be considered realistic and up to now. Is the human composition of society suitable or not?

The purpose UBI intends to achieve is to liberate the labor force of the people to maintain basic survival, so that the people can create freely. It is a very socialist policy and a possible path for human "social evolution", so many countries have A small-scale experiment is underway, but the current 2,000-person experiment in Finland has failed

Critical Review "Unconditional Basic Income" Failed in Finland, Will Spain Succeed With 3.5 Million Unemployed?

https://www.thenewslens.com/article/133486

Of course, this experiment designed by the Finnish government has a sample bias, because they are looking for unemployed people, which may not represent the distribution pattern of the people in the country, but UBI is really testing human nature, in a group of people who have not received UBI thinking training since childhood education People who do experiments on these governments are really naive

In addition to financial resources, this policy also has a key point is to fill the "basic labor force" of society. If everyone throws their labor force to borrowed labor like in developed countries, and the people of these countries are happy to receive UBI, it is not a little bit. Reviving the feeling of the "slave class"? Although it is true that the United States is essentially treating the people of other countries around the world as…